Nineteenth-century prosodists described metrics in terms equally well applicable to Latin and English verse, interpreting English "accent" as comparable to Greek and Latin "quantity." This conceptual ambivalence supported the development of a Romantic, expressive approach to metrical analysis. Beardsley's seminal essay on "The Concept of Meter." Wimsatt and Beardsley developed the concept of "metrical tension" between "accent" and "stress," meter and rhythm, that organizes Lindberg-Seyersted's analysis of Dickinson.ĭavid Perkins' study of nineteenth-century prosody and the scansions that romantic poets themselves created reflects the classical roots of English prosody. This tradition was recodified, in 1959, by W. 3 Not surprisingly, given the classical roots of European criticism, prosody in English developed through Graeco-Roman theory based on the rhythms of Greek and Latin. ORTHOGRAPHY, ETYMOLOGY, SYNTAX, and PROSODY" (13). Lindley Murray's English Grammar, one of the most widely used textbooks in the nineteenth century, defines "ENGLISH GRAMMAR" as "the art of speaking and writing the English language with propriety. Metrics were part of a basic education, taught, as had been the case in antiquity, as part of grammar. In any case, Johnson's original assessment was based on an assumption about Dickinson's education: hymnals provided a "beginner's lesson." But no well-educated person in the nineteenth century would have needed hymnals for a beginner's course in metrics. Judy Jo Small offers a trenchant critique of canonical readings of Dickinson's metrics as hymnal (41-8), arguing, in part, that the Common Meter endemic to English hymns was also widely used by the romantics, Wordsworth employing Common Meter more frequently than any other metric (44). Anthony Hecht argues that hymnal tradition cannot account for the poems' rhetorical structures, as he aligns the poetry with scripture, riddle, and mystical poetics. There has been some resistance to reading the poetry as hymn. Finch reads Dickinson's occasional use of iambic pentameter as a code of patriarchal authority against which Dickinson's use of popular tetrameter and trimeter is figural. Readers such as Martha Winburn England and David Porter read hymnal form symbolically, as a code for traditional authorities against which Dickinson troped her ironic and critical difference. Brita Lindberg-Seyersted follows Johnson and posits a "metrical tension" between the standard forms of the hymn and the "speech rhythms" of Dickinson's verse. 1 Thomas Johnson's reading, which has had canonical force in Dickinson criticism since the 1960s, 2 presents Dickinson as a "self-taught" prosodist who garnered "a beginner's lesson in metrics" from her father's copy of Isaac Watts' hymns and who based her metrical designs in "English hymnology" (84-5). The Emily Dickinson Journal 10.1 (2001) 70-98ĭiscussion of Emily Dickinson's metrics has been remarkably uniform for a poet whose practice routinely suggests something other than familiar manipulation of metrical design. In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |